WALL STREET SMARTS, THE BLOG, IS NOW WALL STREET SMARTS, THE BOOK. FULLY EDITED AND REVISED WITH NEW MATERIAL ON AMAZON
We will conclude our study of Philip Carret and his1930 book, The Art of Speculation, with his final six rules for investing:
7. Avoid "inside information" as you would the plague.
Looking at the psychological aspects of "tips", Mr. Carret said that they appealed to an investor's vanity since such confidential news sets the recipient apart from the rest of the market. He recommended that the investor view him or herself as being the thousandth rather than the first or second person to get the story. Such lack of self pride would, in Mr. Carret's words, be "well rewarded."
8. Seek facts diligently, advice never.
Mr. Carret tells the story of a gentleman who was offered the chance to purchase a significant (1/6th) interest in a new technology company of the time, American Telephone & Telegraph, for $10,000. He sought the advice of a friend in a similar industry, the president of Western Union Telegraph Co., who advised him to save his money. His friend viewed the new invention, the telephone, as impracticable. The president also advised him that Western Union owned patents which gave it a better claim to the invention. The gentleman, unfortunately, took his friend's advice. And, as they say, the rest is history.
9. Ignore mechanical formulas for valuing securities.
Although Mr. Carret recognizes that some measures of a company are helpful, he warns against "unintelligent use of a convenient yardstick of values." He gives the example of the price earnings ratio, which is calculated by dividing a stock price by the prior year's per share earnings. The result represents the price earnings ratio. The higher it is, the more expensive the stock appears to be. Mr. Carret says this ratio is a good start, but the investor can not rely on it alone. Intelligent analysis will always come down to careful consideration of all aspects of both a stock and the company which has issued it.
10. When stocks are high, money rates rising, business prosperous, at least half a given fund should be placed in short-term bonds.
This rule recognizes the cyclical nature of the stock market. When the market in general and an investor's particular stocks have greatly risen in value, an investor should anticipate a drop at some point. This can be seen as a form of market timing in which the investor tries to "buy low and sell high." Mr. Carret is suggesting that at what appears to be a market top, the cautious investor should sell his or her stock and put the proceeds into income producing securities to wait out the imminent and inevitable fall in prices.
11. Borrow money sparingly and only when stocks are low, money rates low or falling, and business depressed.
When Mr. Carret wrote the articles which became his book many individual investors bought their stocks on margin, which means that they put up only a small portion of the purchase price and borrowed the balance from the brokerage house who sold him the stock. If the stock went up in price, then the profits, after repaying the loan, would be larger than if the investor only bought what he or she could afford. The problem was that if the stock went down enough to wipe out the small "equity" held by the investor, the loan was called and the investor would be sold out of the stock by the broker to recoup the loan, resulting in a loss of the entire investment. He is recommending that an investor should borrow on a limited scale and only on occasion. I personally believe that investing on margin is not something for the individual investor. If you own stocks outright, a small decline in price will not affect your holdings.
12. Set aside a moderate proportion of available funds for the purchase of long-term options on stocks of promising companies whenever available.
Mr. Carret is describing the type of security known as option warrants which are usually offered to investors in bonds and preferred stock issues. These can be sold separately from the bonds or preferred stocks they come with. He says that they were offered in many instances to give the broker selling the bonds or preferred stock a "talking point" since they had little initial value and their chances of appreciation were "microscopically small." However, he felt this was a cheap way to get in on the ground floor of a "promising company." This seems a game best left to the "professionals on a closed track", as the TV car commercials warn.
There are two types of history books. The first type is written by a present day historian about events which occurred in the past. The second and, I feel, more interesting type is one written by someone living through the events. Mr. Carret's The Art of Speculation is one of the latter. His very readable book talks about the market from a then current perspective; now, a historical one for us. The book is still in print today, a testament to its continuing value and relevance. It is well worth reading for the beginning investor.
Your comments are always welcome.
Monday, April 18, 2011
Monday, April 11, 2011
Philip L. Carret (2)
WALL STREET SMARTS, THE BLOG, IS NOW WALL STREET SMARTS, THE BOOK. FULLY EDITED AND REVISED WITH NEW MATERIAL ON AMAZON
In his classic, The Art of Speculation, Mr. Carret listed his twelve precepts for fundamental "value" investing. We will look at the first six of them in this blog. They are as follows:
1. Never hold fewer than ten different securities covering five different fields of business.
This provides a minimum amount of diversification; the old rule against keeping all of your eggs in one basket.
2. At least once in six months reappraise every security held.
Mr. Carret suggests that you look at each stock in your portfolio and ask whether you would buy the same stock for the same price it is selling at today. The price you paid for the stock is irrelevant in this exercise. You are looking at the investment anew. If your answer would be no, then he recommends selling it and reinvesting the proceeds. The time period is long enough to prevent the investor from falling into the trap of over trading, a guaranteed road to losses.
3. Keep at least half the total fund in income-producing securities.
At the time Mr. Carret wrote this, income-producing securities, corporate or government bonds paying interest, were considered a higher grade of investments than common stocks that did not pay any dividend. The risk of loss was considered significantly smaller. The investment quality of the bonds was the attraction, not the income itself. In down markets, bonds retained more of their value than stocks. However, bonds can lose value as a result of interest rate changes in the market.
4. Consider yield the least important factor in analyzing any stock.
Mr. Carret explains that the speculative investor is mainly interested in an increase in the market value of the stock he or she purchases. The dividend income is not the goal. If the investor needs income from the funds, Mr. Carret considered that a sign the investor could not afford to speculate in the first place. I agree with this rule, but I feel it may not necessarily apply to an investor in retirement. At that point, the investor is presumably looking for some income as well as appreciation.
5. Be quick to take losses, reluctant to take profits.
The underlying assumption for his statement is that the investor is looking for a long term increase in the value of his or her investment portfolio, not quick trading profits. You will hear the old adage, "You'll never go broke taking profits," from your broker who, of course, makes a living on the commissions earned from your frequent buying and selling. The other beneficiary of frequent trading profits is the tax man, who will expect his "commission" to be paid as well.
6. Never put more than 25% of a given fund into securities about which detailed information is not readily and regularly available.
In the 1920's before there were federal securities regulations, there were few if any requirements that public companies provide financial information about their business to the public. Only the large shareholders, directors and officers knew what was really going on. The individual investor back then had to work hard to learn much of anything about the state of affairs of the companies in which he or she had invested. Such is not the case today. US and many other countries' securities laws require companies to file periodic reports about the results of operations with the Securities & Exchange Commission (SEC) in the USA or the equivalent in other countries. These reports, at least in the US, are available to investors at little or no charge. The reporting requirements are usually not as stringent for smaller public companies, so this advice still holds true today. If you can't easily and readily learn about a company's business operations and results on a regular basis, you probably should not invest in its stock.
We will learn the other six rules next Monday.
As always, your comments are welcome.
In his classic, The Art of Speculation, Mr. Carret listed his twelve precepts for fundamental "value" investing. We will look at the first six of them in this blog. They are as follows:
1. Never hold fewer than ten different securities covering five different fields of business.
This provides a minimum amount of diversification; the old rule against keeping all of your eggs in one basket.
2. At least once in six months reappraise every security held.
Mr. Carret suggests that you look at each stock in your portfolio and ask whether you would buy the same stock for the same price it is selling at today. The price you paid for the stock is irrelevant in this exercise. You are looking at the investment anew. If your answer would be no, then he recommends selling it and reinvesting the proceeds. The time period is long enough to prevent the investor from falling into the trap of over trading, a guaranteed road to losses.
3. Keep at least half the total fund in income-producing securities.
At the time Mr. Carret wrote this, income-producing securities, corporate or government bonds paying interest, were considered a higher grade of investments than common stocks that did not pay any dividend. The risk of loss was considered significantly smaller. The investment quality of the bonds was the attraction, not the income itself. In down markets, bonds retained more of their value than stocks. However, bonds can lose value as a result of interest rate changes in the market.
4. Consider yield the least important factor in analyzing any stock.
Mr. Carret explains that the speculative investor is mainly interested in an increase in the market value of the stock he or she purchases. The dividend income is not the goal. If the investor needs income from the funds, Mr. Carret considered that a sign the investor could not afford to speculate in the first place. I agree with this rule, but I feel it may not necessarily apply to an investor in retirement. At that point, the investor is presumably looking for some income as well as appreciation.
5. Be quick to take losses, reluctant to take profits.
The underlying assumption for his statement is that the investor is looking for a long term increase in the value of his or her investment portfolio, not quick trading profits. You will hear the old adage, "You'll never go broke taking profits," from your broker who, of course, makes a living on the commissions earned from your frequent buying and selling. The other beneficiary of frequent trading profits is the tax man, who will expect his "commission" to be paid as well.
6. Never put more than 25% of a given fund into securities about which detailed information is not readily and regularly available.
In the 1920's before there were federal securities regulations, there were few if any requirements that public companies provide financial information about their business to the public. Only the large shareholders, directors and officers knew what was really going on. The individual investor back then had to work hard to learn much of anything about the state of affairs of the companies in which he or she had invested. Such is not the case today. US and many other countries' securities laws require companies to file periodic reports about the results of operations with the Securities & Exchange Commission (SEC) in the USA or the equivalent in other countries. These reports, at least in the US, are available to investors at little or no charge. The reporting requirements are usually not as stringent for smaller public companies, so this advice still holds true today. If you can't easily and readily learn about a company's business operations and results on a regular basis, you probably should not invest in its stock.
We will learn the other six rules next Monday.
As always, your comments are welcome.
Monday, April 4, 2011
Philip L. Carret (1)
WALL STREET SMARTS, THE BLOG, IS NOW WALL STREET SMARTS, THE BOOK. FULLY EDITED AND REVISED WITH NEW MATERIAL ON AMAZON
Philip L. Carret was one of the early proponents of "value" investing, one of the forms of fundamental analysis. He wrote a series of articles for Barron's, a weekly financial publication, in 1926. Those articles became a book, The Art of Speculation, which was first published in 1930. One of Mr. Carret's many claims to fame was his founding in 1928 of the Fidelity Mutual Trust (now the Pioneer Fund), one of only five investment trusts (now we call them mutual funds) on Wall Street at the time. The Pioneer Fund continues today, making it the third oldest mutual fund on Wall Street. Like the Pioneer Fund, Mr. Carret had one of the longest careers on Wall Street, remaining active in the markets for more than 70+ years. He was one of the few people on Wall Street who experienced first hand the market crashes of both 1929 and 1987. At the time he wrote his articles in 1926, the term "speculation" had some of the same negative connotations that still exist today. This is what he had to say:
What, after all, is speculation? The redoubtable Webster gives a number of definitions. Among them we find (1) "mental view of anything in its various aspects; intellectual examination"; (2) "the act or practice of buying land or goods, etc., in expectation of the rise of price and of selling them at an advance." To the second he added the complacent observation that "a few men have been enriched but many have been ruined by speculation." According to Webster, the motive is the test by which we must distinguish between an investment and a speculative transaction. The man who bought United States Steel at 60 in 1915 in anticipation of selling at a profit is a speculator according to Webster, though he may have changed his mind about selling and added the stock to his list of permanent investments. On the other hand, the gentleman who bought American Telephone at 95 in 1921 to enjoy the dividend return of better than 8% is an investor, though he may have succumbed to the temptation of a 10-point profit a few weeks later. Although the outcome of the transaction may contradict the original intention of the party chiefly interested, it is obviously impossible to omit the factor of motive in defining speculation.
Mr. Carret maintained that speculation is just a point on the investment spectrum. He provided the following insight:
Your articles deal with speculative investment rather than with speculation," said an astute observer of both fields of activity when he had read the greater part of this book in serial form. To this charge the writer was forced to plead guilty. After all it is by no means easy to draw the line between investment and speculation, between speculation and gambling. If one is to discuss the topic of speculation and perhaps thereby induce some readers to attempt it who might otherwise have left speculation alone, it is much more helpful to the average reader, much less dangerous to the reader who might misinterpret what he reads, to discuss that sort of speculation which is on the borderland of investment than the more dangerous and less useful type of speculation which borders on gambling. Perhaps the best sort of speculation, and the kind that is most likely to be successful, is that which regards it as the business management of a fund. What does the manager of a business do? He controls men, materials and money, seeking to handle them in such a way that the business will produce a profit. Conceiving the speculator as manager of a business it will be seen that he also controls men, materials and money. The money is the starting point of his business, the materials are the securities which he buys and sells, the men are the directors and managers of the companies in whose securities he invests.
We will return to Mr. Carret's classic on investing in the next blog to learn about his twelve precepts for the speculative investor. The sixth printing of The Art of Speculation by Philip L. Carret, published in 1995 by Fraser Publishing Company, remains in print today.
Comments are always welcome. On April 7th, this upcoming Thursday, I will be a guest on Lake Effect, a radio program on the Milwaukee public radio station, WUWM, 89.7 FM. I will be talking about this blog site. You can listen to the podcast after 11:00 am Milwaukee time on WUWM.COM.
Philip L. Carret was one of the early proponents of "value" investing, one of the forms of fundamental analysis. He wrote a series of articles for Barron's, a weekly financial publication, in 1926. Those articles became a book, The Art of Speculation, which was first published in 1930. One of Mr. Carret's many claims to fame was his founding in 1928 of the Fidelity Mutual Trust (now the Pioneer Fund), one of only five investment trusts (now we call them mutual funds) on Wall Street at the time. The Pioneer Fund continues today, making it the third oldest mutual fund on Wall Street. Like the Pioneer Fund, Mr. Carret had one of the longest careers on Wall Street, remaining active in the markets for more than 70+ years. He was one of the few people on Wall Street who experienced first hand the market crashes of both 1929 and 1987. At the time he wrote his articles in 1926, the term "speculation" had some of the same negative connotations that still exist today. This is what he had to say:
What, after all, is speculation? The redoubtable Webster gives a number of definitions. Among them we find (1) "mental view of anything in its various aspects; intellectual examination"; (2) "the act or practice of buying land or goods, etc., in expectation of the rise of price and of selling them at an advance." To the second he added the complacent observation that "a few men have been enriched but many have been ruined by speculation." According to Webster, the motive is the test by which we must distinguish between an investment and a speculative transaction. The man who bought United States Steel at 60 in 1915 in anticipation of selling at a profit is a speculator according to Webster, though he may have changed his mind about selling and added the stock to his list of permanent investments. On the other hand, the gentleman who bought American Telephone at 95 in 1921 to enjoy the dividend return of better than 8% is an investor, though he may have succumbed to the temptation of a 10-point profit a few weeks later. Although the outcome of the transaction may contradict the original intention of the party chiefly interested, it is obviously impossible to omit the factor of motive in defining speculation.
Mr. Carret maintained that speculation is just a point on the investment spectrum. He provided the following insight:
Your articles deal with speculative investment rather than with speculation," said an astute observer of both fields of activity when he had read the greater part of this book in serial form. To this charge the writer was forced to plead guilty. After all it is by no means easy to draw the line between investment and speculation, between speculation and gambling. If one is to discuss the topic of speculation and perhaps thereby induce some readers to attempt it who might otherwise have left speculation alone, it is much more helpful to the average reader, much less dangerous to the reader who might misinterpret what he reads, to discuss that sort of speculation which is on the borderland of investment than the more dangerous and less useful type of speculation which borders on gambling. Perhaps the best sort of speculation, and the kind that is most likely to be successful, is that which regards it as the business management of a fund. What does the manager of a business do? He controls men, materials and money, seeking to handle them in such a way that the business will produce a profit. Conceiving the speculator as manager of a business it will be seen that he also controls men, materials and money. The money is the starting point of his business, the materials are the securities which he buys and sells, the men are the directors and managers of the companies in whose securities he invests.
We will return to Mr. Carret's classic on investing in the next blog to learn about his twelve precepts for the speculative investor. The sixth printing of The Art of Speculation by Philip L. Carret, published in 1995 by Fraser Publishing Company, remains in print today.
Comments are always welcome. On April 7th, this upcoming Thursday, I will be a guest on Lake Effect, a radio program on the Milwaukee public radio station, WUWM, 89.7 FM. I will be talking about this blog site. You can listen to the podcast after 11:00 am Milwaukee time on WUWM.COM.
Monday, March 28, 2011
Gold Mining, Hang Gliding and Power Walking
WALL STREET SMARTS, THE BLOG, IS NOW WALL STREET SMARTS, THE BOOK. FULLY EDITED AND REVISED WITH NEW MATERIAL ON AMAZON
You can roughly divide investment strategies into three overall types: fundamental analysis, technical analysis and efficient market theory. Each one has subsets, but a majority of fundamental investors study the financial condition and prospects of a company in which they might invest. Most technical investors pay attention to price levels either of the market in general or of a particular stock and try to determine the probable direction in which either or both of them might be headed. Proponents of efficient market theory reject the other two and believe a stock's price says it all.
Those investors who make investments based on fundamental analysis, the gold miners, spend the majority of their time looking for public companies with financial characteristics they feel will lead to an investment profit. They analyze things like the company's price earnings ratio, debt to equity level, asset to liability ratio, revenue and earnings growth rates, return on assets or on equity, profit margins, dividend payout ratios, interest coverage ratios, quality of management, overall prospects of the general industry in which the company does business and the like. The goal is to find a company whose financial strength and business prospects are such that an investment in its stock will increase over time with the anticipated growth of the company's finances, business and profits. They are searching for gold nuggets in a mine full of financial data.
Those investors who look to technical analysis, the hang gliders, spend the majority of their time looking at either the state of the market in general and the way its overall price level is acting or a stock in particular and its price movement. They pay attention to the price action of a stock, not its financial characteristics. They analyze things like 65 and 200 day average price movements, trading volumes, advances and declines in prices, prices being held at or breaking through resistance levels, price charts and the like. The goal is to find a company whose stock price is behaving in a way that signals the opportunity to profit from its anticipated momentum. They want to catch the wind and ride it to a profit.
Those investors who rely on the efficient market theory, which was developed by academics in university economics and business schools, believe that markets constantly and efficiently set the price of each and every stock in the market. Since the market price reflects everything known about a stock at the time, neither fundamental nor technical analysis provides an investor with any benefit or advantage. This is popularly referred to as the random walk theory of investing.
Fundamental investors see a stock as an investment in and an ownership of a company's business. Technical investors see a stock mainly in terms of its price and the probable direction in which that price will move. Random walk investors see a stock price as revealing everything there is to know about a company and its stock at that moment.
We will examine each of these schools of thought, their proponents and heroes in subsequent blogs. We will start with a famous fundamental stock analyst, Philip L. Carret, in the next blog.
Feel free to leave a comment. Using the Anonymous profile is the easiest way to post one.
You can roughly divide investment strategies into three overall types: fundamental analysis, technical analysis and efficient market theory. Each one has subsets, but a majority of fundamental investors study the financial condition and prospects of a company in which they might invest. Most technical investors pay attention to price levels either of the market in general or of a particular stock and try to determine the probable direction in which either or both of them might be headed. Proponents of efficient market theory reject the other two and believe a stock's price says it all.
Those investors who make investments based on fundamental analysis, the gold miners, spend the majority of their time looking for public companies with financial characteristics they feel will lead to an investment profit. They analyze things like the company's price earnings ratio, debt to equity level, asset to liability ratio, revenue and earnings growth rates, return on assets or on equity, profit margins, dividend payout ratios, interest coverage ratios, quality of management, overall prospects of the general industry in which the company does business and the like. The goal is to find a company whose financial strength and business prospects are such that an investment in its stock will increase over time with the anticipated growth of the company's finances, business and profits. They are searching for gold nuggets in a mine full of financial data.
Those investors who look to technical analysis, the hang gliders, spend the majority of their time looking at either the state of the market in general and the way its overall price level is acting or a stock in particular and its price movement. They pay attention to the price action of a stock, not its financial characteristics. They analyze things like 65 and 200 day average price movements, trading volumes, advances and declines in prices, prices being held at or breaking through resistance levels, price charts and the like. The goal is to find a company whose stock price is behaving in a way that signals the opportunity to profit from its anticipated momentum. They want to catch the wind and ride it to a profit.
Those investors who rely on the efficient market theory, which was developed by academics in university economics and business schools, believe that markets constantly and efficiently set the price of each and every stock in the market. Since the market price reflects everything known about a stock at the time, neither fundamental nor technical analysis provides an investor with any benefit or advantage. This is popularly referred to as the random walk theory of investing.
Fundamental investors see a stock as an investment in and an ownership of a company's business. Technical investors see a stock mainly in terms of its price and the probable direction in which that price will move. Random walk investors see a stock price as revealing everything there is to know about a company and its stock at that moment.
We will examine each of these schools of thought, their proponents and heroes in subsequent blogs. We will start with a famous fundamental stock analyst, Philip L. Carret, in the next blog.
Feel free to leave a comment. Using the Anonymous profile is the easiest way to post one.
Monday, March 21, 2011
Some Simple Truths
WALL STREET SMARTS, THE BLOG, IS NOW WALL STREET SMARTS, THE BOOK. FULLY EDITED AND REVISED WITH NEW MATERIAL ON AMAZON
YOU CAN'T PLAY SOLITAIRE ON WALL STREET
There are days when the market declines for no apparent reason. When asked why, someone will invariably say, "More sellers than buyers." I must admit to being guilty of that comment a time or two. But I finally realized the comment was wrong. When the market is open, each stock has a bid quote from a buyer and an ask quote from a seller. There is a buyer for every seller; the people are there. However, a person can not be a seller if no one takes the other side of the trade at the seller's price. There is a bidder on the other side, but his or her bid is not at the price the seller is asking. If a seller wants or needs to sell and the price is not rising, then sooner or later he or she will have to accept a lower price. That is what makes for a decline. Perhaps the more accurate way to explain a market decline is to say, "More desire to sell than appetite to buy." The same holds true, in reverse, for a market rising for no apparent reason. Then it's, "More appetite to buy than desire to sell."
IT'S ALL RELATIVE
One stock; one price; one moment in time. For someone who bought the stock at a lower price, that price represents a profit, albeit on paper. For someone who bought it at a higher price, the same price represents a paper loss. Someone who decides to sell at a profit, in many instances, thinks the stock has gotten as high as it might and wants to lock in the gain before it drops. That seller's buyer, on the other hand, thinks the stock will go to a much higher price. Someone who sells at a loss, in many instances, thinks the stock will continue to go lower and wants to stop the bleeding. That seller's buyer, on the other hand, thinks the stock is ready to turn around and head higher. One stock; one price; one moment in time. With a nod to Albert Einstein, the price is, indeed, relative, dependent on an investor's position in relation to the current price and his or her idea of its next movement. Each price generates two different views of the same stock's relative value at that time and its future.
UNREQUITED LOVE
Adam Smith in his book, The Money Game, warns about becoming emotionally invested in a stock you own in the following passage:
You can see that all this is leading to another of Smith's Irregular Rules, this one that the identity of the investor and that of the investing action must be coldly separate. A stock is, for all practical purposes, a piece of paper that sits in a bank vault. Most likely you will never see it. It may or may not have an Intrinsic Value, what it is worth on any given day depends on the confluence of buyers and sellers that day. The most important thing to realize is simple: The stock doesn't know you own it. All those marvelous things, or those terrible things, that you feel about a stock, or a list of stocks, or an amount of money represented by a list of stocks, all of those things are unreciprocated by the stock or group of stocks. You can be in love if you want to, but that piece of paper doesn't love you, and unreciprocated love can turn into masochism, narcissism, or, even worse, market losses and unreciprocated hate.
An investor should try to keep all of this in mind when coming to the market. In the next blog, we will start exploring the ways investors approach investing in stocks.
The passage from The Money Game by Adam Smith, copyright 1967, 1968 by Adam Smith is reprinted with permission of Random House, Inc.
Your comments are always welcome and will be posted within 24 hours of receipt.
YOU CAN'T PLAY SOLITAIRE ON WALL STREET
There are days when the market declines for no apparent reason. When asked why, someone will invariably say, "More sellers than buyers." I must admit to being guilty of that comment a time or two. But I finally realized the comment was wrong. When the market is open, each stock has a bid quote from a buyer and an ask quote from a seller. There is a buyer for every seller; the people are there. However, a person can not be a seller if no one takes the other side of the trade at the seller's price. There is a bidder on the other side, but his or her bid is not at the price the seller is asking. If a seller wants or needs to sell and the price is not rising, then sooner or later he or she will have to accept a lower price. That is what makes for a decline. Perhaps the more accurate way to explain a market decline is to say, "More desire to sell than appetite to buy." The same holds true, in reverse, for a market rising for no apparent reason. Then it's, "More appetite to buy than desire to sell."
IT'S ALL RELATIVE
One stock; one price; one moment in time. For someone who bought the stock at a lower price, that price represents a profit, albeit on paper. For someone who bought it at a higher price, the same price represents a paper loss. Someone who decides to sell at a profit, in many instances, thinks the stock has gotten as high as it might and wants to lock in the gain before it drops. That seller's buyer, on the other hand, thinks the stock will go to a much higher price. Someone who sells at a loss, in many instances, thinks the stock will continue to go lower and wants to stop the bleeding. That seller's buyer, on the other hand, thinks the stock is ready to turn around and head higher. One stock; one price; one moment in time. With a nod to Albert Einstein, the price is, indeed, relative, dependent on an investor's position in relation to the current price and his or her idea of its next movement. Each price generates two different views of the same stock's relative value at that time and its future.
UNREQUITED LOVE
Adam Smith in his book, The Money Game, warns about becoming emotionally invested in a stock you own in the following passage:
You can see that all this is leading to another of Smith's Irregular Rules, this one that the identity of the investor and that of the investing action must be coldly separate. A stock is, for all practical purposes, a piece of paper that sits in a bank vault. Most likely you will never see it. It may or may not have an Intrinsic Value, what it is worth on any given day depends on the confluence of buyers and sellers that day. The most important thing to realize is simple: The stock doesn't know you own it. All those marvelous things, or those terrible things, that you feel about a stock, or a list of stocks, or an amount of money represented by a list of stocks, all of those things are unreciprocated by the stock or group of stocks. You can be in love if you want to, but that piece of paper doesn't love you, and unreciprocated love can turn into masochism, narcissism, or, even worse, market losses and unreciprocated hate.
An investor should try to keep all of this in mind when coming to the market. In the next blog, we will start exploring the ways investors approach investing in stocks.
The passage from The Money Game by Adam Smith, copyright 1967, 1968 by Adam Smith is reprinted with permission of Random House, Inc.
Your comments are always welcome and will be posted within 24 hours of receipt.
Monday, March 14, 2011
The Final Monday With The Venture Capitalists
WALL STREET SMARTS, THE BLOG, IS NOW WALL STREET SMARTS, THE BOOK. FULLY EDITED AND REVISED WITH NEW MATERIAL ON AMAZON
This Monday we are again meeting with the folks from Venture Funds, Inc. (VFI) to wrap up the negotiations for their investment in Best Blogs Ever, Inc. (BBE). We have agreed that VFI's $70,000 investment will be divided between a minority interest in the common stock of BBE and its new issue of preferred shares. Provisions in BBE's Articles of Incorporation establishing the preferred shares will provide for the cumulative and convertible rights negotiated last Monday. Today, VFI's representatives suggest that the preferred shares also share in any future increase in dividends declared by the board of directors for the common stock. In most instances, preferred shares receive a fixed dividend regardless of the amount of earnings of a company, much like interest to be paid on a bank loan. Increased earnings can translate into increased dividends for common shares. Preferred stock sharing in dividend increases paid on common shares is called participating preferred stock. We reject this proposal. Our treasurer points out that since VFI will own common shares, it will participate, to a certain extent, in any future increase in common stock dividends.
After some further discussion, the deal is reached. Everyone agrees that BBE will amend its Articles of Incorporation to increase the number of authorized shares from the original 1,000 shares of common stock to 10,000 authorized shares with a par value of $1 each. There had been earlier discussions about more shares being authorized, but to keep the math simple, 10,000 shares at $1 par value is the agreed upon number. This is equivalent to the original 1,000 authorized shares with $10 par value. BBE will have 9,500 shares authorized, but unissued shares of common stock plus the original 500 issued and outstanding shares. With that many shares now authorized, the board of directors will declare a stock split of the issued shares on a 10 for 1 basis. The original 500 outstanding shares with a par value of $10 each will become 5,000 shares with a par value of $1 each. The existing shareholders will continue to own the increased number of issued shares in their original percentages.
Based on BBE's earnings of $5,000 for the last year of operations and its retained earnings of $10,000, the old 500 shares might be valued at $30 per share ($10 par value and $20 per share of retained earnings). Those figures are reduced for the 5,000 split shares by a factor of 10. The new 5,000 shares could be valued at $3 per share. The $1,500 of dividends would now be shared in the same proportion. Before the stock split, each of the original shares received a $3 dividend. The 5,000 shares would now receive a 30 cent per share dividend. Someone recalls our president's previous joke about the customer asking for his pizza to be cut into 4 slices as opposed to 8 because he is not that hungry. The income and dividend numbers continue to apply; they are just spread among more shares.
When VFI purchases common shares, those numbers will be divided among even more shares. In order to allow the original shareholders to retain control of BBE, VFI will purchase 4,000 shares of common stock. Although the par value for the new shares is $1, VFI agrees to pay $2.50 for each share of common stock. The par value has continued to lose its meaning, and it now becomes even less important. The value of a share of common stock is not its par value or its book value, but rather what someone will pay for it. Consequently, BBE will issue 4,000 shares of common stock to VFI for a purchase price of $10,000. After that, BBE will still have 1,000 authorized but unissued shares of common stock. VFI will also purchase 600 shares of cumulative, convertible preferred stock with a par value of $100 per share. Unlike par value for the common shares, the par value for the preferred shares does matter. The preferred shares will have a yield (their fixed dividend) of 2% per share. BBE will pay $1200 in annual dividends on the 600 preferred shares. Based on the most recent declared dividend of $1,500, this leaves only $300 in dividends for the common shares. Everyone hopes that the earnings will continue to increase, resulting in an increase in the dividend paid on the larger number of issued shares. The original shareholders retain the control they want, but they have to give up dividends to get it. If the directors of BBE were to decide, for financial reasons, not to pay the preferred dividend for three consecutive years, VFI will have the right to convert its preferred shares into common stock, again on a 10 to 1 basis.
Focusing on the possibility of such a conversion, we realize that the Articles of Incorporation must authorize more common shares than the 10,000 we had initially proposed in order to keep the par value in balance. Everyone agrees that the par value is not that important any more except for accounting purposes. Our treasurer assures us that it is not a problem to get rid of par value for the common stock. Both sides agree that the Articles will authorize a total of 50,000 common shares with no par value and 600 preferred shares each with a $100 par value. If the preferred stock were to be converted because no dividend had been paid for three years, the 600 shares of preferred could be converted by VFI into 6,000 shares of common. This would give VFI a total of 10,000 shares of common stock, enough to outvote the 5,000 shares held by the original shareholders. Since the preferred shares always remain worth their par value, VFI would also have the right to convert the preferred shares into common if BBE is sold to other investors or taken public. By converting the preferred to common, VFI can share in any increase in the value of BBE and, consequently, its common stock. With final agreement reached, the legal papers are completed, and VFI's money is received. BBE buys the servers, expands the office and hires new employees.
We will end BBE's story here. We may return to it in the future if we need to learn more financial terms. I patterned this vocabulary lesson on a similar but much more detailed story contained in an excellent investment book, How to Buy Stocks, a guide to successful investing, written by Louis Engel in 1953. Since its initial publication, this book, which was the first one I ever read, has gone through 8 revised editions. With each edition, the book is updated to reflect changes in the stock market and the investments one can find there. Despite this, the basic message of Mr. Engel's classic has been retained through all these years. The most recent edition, which is still in print, was revised by Henry R. Hecht in 1994. In light of its many editions over the last 50+ years, it is obvious that both beginning and veteran investors find it to be a great resource for learning about investing. You can click on the Amazon link above to buy a paperback copy.
Comments are always welcome (best to use the Anonymous profile). All are posted within 24 hours of receipt. I reply to comments on Fridays.
This Monday we are again meeting with the folks from Venture Funds, Inc. (VFI) to wrap up the negotiations for their investment in Best Blogs Ever, Inc. (BBE). We have agreed that VFI's $70,000 investment will be divided between a minority interest in the common stock of BBE and its new issue of preferred shares. Provisions in BBE's Articles of Incorporation establishing the preferred shares will provide for the cumulative and convertible rights negotiated last Monday. Today, VFI's representatives suggest that the preferred shares also share in any future increase in dividends declared by the board of directors for the common stock. In most instances, preferred shares receive a fixed dividend regardless of the amount of earnings of a company, much like interest to be paid on a bank loan. Increased earnings can translate into increased dividends for common shares. Preferred stock sharing in dividend increases paid on common shares is called participating preferred stock. We reject this proposal. Our treasurer points out that since VFI will own common shares, it will participate, to a certain extent, in any future increase in common stock dividends.
After some further discussion, the deal is reached. Everyone agrees that BBE will amend its Articles of Incorporation to increase the number of authorized shares from the original 1,000 shares of common stock to 10,000 authorized shares with a par value of $1 each. There had been earlier discussions about more shares being authorized, but to keep the math simple, 10,000 shares at $1 par value is the agreed upon number. This is equivalent to the original 1,000 authorized shares with $10 par value. BBE will have 9,500 shares authorized, but unissued shares of common stock plus the original 500 issued and outstanding shares. With that many shares now authorized, the board of directors will declare a stock split of the issued shares on a 10 for 1 basis. The original 500 outstanding shares with a par value of $10 each will become 5,000 shares with a par value of $1 each. The existing shareholders will continue to own the increased number of issued shares in their original percentages.
Based on BBE's earnings of $5,000 for the last year of operations and its retained earnings of $10,000, the old 500 shares might be valued at $30 per share ($10 par value and $20 per share of retained earnings). Those figures are reduced for the 5,000 split shares by a factor of 10. The new 5,000 shares could be valued at $3 per share. The $1,500 of dividends would now be shared in the same proportion. Before the stock split, each of the original shares received a $3 dividend. The 5,000 shares would now receive a 30 cent per share dividend. Someone recalls our president's previous joke about the customer asking for his pizza to be cut into 4 slices as opposed to 8 because he is not that hungry. The income and dividend numbers continue to apply; they are just spread among more shares.
When VFI purchases common shares, those numbers will be divided among even more shares. In order to allow the original shareholders to retain control of BBE, VFI will purchase 4,000 shares of common stock. Although the par value for the new shares is $1, VFI agrees to pay $2.50 for each share of common stock. The par value has continued to lose its meaning, and it now becomes even less important. The value of a share of common stock is not its par value or its book value, but rather what someone will pay for it. Consequently, BBE will issue 4,000 shares of common stock to VFI for a purchase price of $10,000. After that, BBE will still have 1,000 authorized but unissued shares of common stock. VFI will also purchase 600 shares of cumulative, convertible preferred stock with a par value of $100 per share. Unlike par value for the common shares, the par value for the preferred shares does matter. The preferred shares will have a yield (their fixed dividend) of 2% per share. BBE will pay $1200 in annual dividends on the 600 preferred shares. Based on the most recent declared dividend of $1,500, this leaves only $300 in dividends for the common shares. Everyone hopes that the earnings will continue to increase, resulting in an increase in the dividend paid on the larger number of issued shares. The original shareholders retain the control they want, but they have to give up dividends to get it. If the directors of BBE were to decide, for financial reasons, not to pay the preferred dividend for three consecutive years, VFI will have the right to convert its preferred shares into common stock, again on a 10 to 1 basis.
Focusing on the possibility of such a conversion, we realize that the Articles of Incorporation must authorize more common shares than the 10,000 we had initially proposed in order to keep the par value in balance. Everyone agrees that the par value is not that important any more except for accounting purposes. Our treasurer assures us that it is not a problem to get rid of par value for the common stock. Both sides agree that the Articles will authorize a total of 50,000 common shares with no par value and 600 preferred shares each with a $100 par value. If the preferred stock were to be converted because no dividend had been paid for three years, the 600 shares of preferred could be converted by VFI into 6,000 shares of common. This would give VFI a total of 10,000 shares of common stock, enough to outvote the 5,000 shares held by the original shareholders. Since the preferred shares always remain worth their par value, VFI would also have the right to convert the preferred shares into common if BBE is sold to other investors or taken public. By converting the preferred to common, VFI can share in any increase in the value of BBE and, consequently, its common stock. With final agreement reached, the legal papers are completed, and VFI's money is received. BBE buys the servers, expands the office and hires new employees.
We will end BBE's story here. We may return to it in the future if we need to learn more financial terms. I patterned this vocabulary lesson on a similar but much more detailed story contained in an excellent investment book, How to Buy Stocks, a guide to successful investing, written by Louis Engel in 1953. Since its initial publication, this book, which was the first one I ever read, has gone through 8 revised editions. With each edition, the book is updated to reflect changes in the stock market and the investments one can find there. Despite this, the basic message of Mr. Engel's classic has been retained through all these years. The most recent edition, which is still in print, was revised by Henry R. Hecht in 1994. In light of its many editions over the last 50+ years, it is obvious that both beginning and veteran investors find it to be a great resource for learning about investing. You can click on the Amazon link above to buy a paperback copy.
Comments are always welcome (best to use the Anonymous profile). All are posted within 24 hours of receipt. I reply to comments on Fridays.
Monday, March 7, 2011
Round Two of Negotiations with the VCs
WALL STREET SMARTS, THE BLOG, IS NOW WALL STREET SMARTS, THE BOOK. FULLY EDITED AND REVISED WITH NEW MATERIAL ON AMAZON
Another Monday and another meeting with Kate, Daniel and Susan, the representatives of Venture Funds, Inc. (VFI). This time we are meeting at their offices to continue discussions about a VFI investment in Best Blogs Ever, Inc. (BBE). At the end of our last meeting with the venture capitalists, everyone had agreed that they would purchase a minority interest in BBE's common stock. They would invest the balance of the needed $70,000 in BBE by purchasing its new issue of preferred stock.
The discussion quickly became focused on the rights the preferred stock would have in exchange for not having a vote. Daniel said that preferred stock receives a fixed dividend that the company would be required to pay annually. That would make the preferred stock dividend much like a loan payment to a bank. Mary Jo, our financial consultant, indicated that the earnings of BBE were not steady. They fluctuated yearly. What should happen if there were not enough earnings in a year to pay any dividend? The board of directors of BBE had to have the discretion not to declare a dividend. They had to have the ability to pass on the dividend for the preferred and the common stock in a year in which BBE had either poor earnings or a loss. Our treasurer proposed that the preferred stock dividend would have to be paid before any dividend could be declared by the board of directors for the common shares. This is a fairly common right granted to preferred stock holders.
It was agreed that the directors of BBE would have the right not declare any dividends; however, there would be a cumulative dividend provision in the Articles of Incorporation. If a company has cumulative preferred stock, then any and all unpaid dividends on the preferred shares must be repaid before the common shares could receive any dividends. Kate suggested that if the company was unable to pay the preferred stock dividend for a number of years, this would be an indication that the company was not being run properly. In that case, VFI should have a right to take control of the company and install a new board of directors. The new board could elect new officers to manage the company. New managers might be able to increase earnings and restore the dividend. Since VFI had agreed to buy a minority of the common stock so the original shareholders could maintain control, it would need to gain more common shares in order to outvote the original shareholders.
Susan said that a way to provide VFI with additional shares of common stock would be to add a convertibility provision to the Articles. If the preferred stock dividend was not paid for a number of consecutive years, then VFI would have the right to convert some or all of its preferred shares into common shares with voting rights. Preferred shares with that type of right are called convertible preferred shares. The convertibility provision would set forth how and when the preferred shares could be converted. She also pointed out that if BBE were to be sold to another company or group of investors, VFI's preferred shares would not share in any increase in the value of the company. Preferred shares do not appreciate in value. Their value remains at the original purchase price, and the owners receive their investment back if the shares are redeemed. She proposed that the VFI's preferred shares should also be convertible into common shares if the shareholders voted to sell BBE or take it public at some point in the future. By converting the preferred shares into common, VFI would share in any increase in the value of BBE and any consequent appreciation in the common shares.
The parties agree to meet again next Monday. This will give each side the opportunity to consider the issues raised in today's discussions.
If there is any financial term you would like explained, please submit it in a comment and I will try to answer your question.
Comments are always welcome and are posted within 24 hours of receipt.
Another Monday and another meeting with Kate, Daniel and Susan, the representatives of Venture Funds, Inc. (VFI). This time we are meeting at their offices to continue discussions about a VFI investment in Best Blogs Ever, Inc. (BBE). At the end of our last meeting with the venture capitalists, everyone had agreed that they would purchase a minority interest in BBE's common stock. They would invest the balance of the needed $70,000 in BBE by purchasing its new issue of preferred stock.
The discussion quickly became focused on the rights the preferred stock would have in exchange for not having a vote. Daniel said that preferred stock receives a fixed dividend that the company would be required to pay annually. That would make the preferred stock dividend much like a loan payment to a bank. Mary Jo, our financial consultant, indicated that the earnings of BBE were not steady. They fluctuated yearly. What should happen if there were not enough earnings in a year to pay any dividend? The board of directors of BBE had to have the discretion not to declare a dividend. They had to have the ability to pass on the dividend for the preferred and the common stock in a year in which BBE had either poor earnings or a loss. Our treasurer proposed that the preferred stock dividend would have to be paid before any dividend could be declared by the board of directors for the common shares. This is a fairly common right granted to preferred stock holders.
It was agreed that the directors of BBE would have the right not declare any dividends; however, there would be a cumulative dividend provision in the Articles of Incorporation. If a company has cumulative preferred stock, then any and all unpaid dividends on the preferred shares must be repaid before the common shares could receive any dividends. Kate suggested that if the company was unable to pay the preferred stock dividend for a number of years, this would be an indication that the company was not being run properly. In that case, VFI should have a right to take control of the company and install a new board of directors. The new board could elect new officers to manage the company. New managers might be able to increase earnings and restore the dividend. Since VFI had agreed to buy a minority of the common stock so the original shareholders could maintain control, it would need to gain more common shares in order to outvote the original shareholders.
Susan said that a way to provide VFI with additional shares of common stock would be to add a convertibility provision to the Articles. If the preferred stock dividend was not paid for a number of consecutive years, then VFI would have the right to convert some or all of its preferred shares into common shares with voting rights. Preferred shares with that type of right are called convertible preferred shares. The convertibility provision would set forth how and when the preferred shares could be converted. She also pointed out that if BBE were to be sold to another company or group of investors, VFI's preferred shares would not share in any increase in the value of the company. Preferred shares do not appreciate in value. Their value remains at the original purchase price, and the owners receive their investment back if the shares are redeemed. She proposed that the VFI's preferred shares should also be convertible into common shares if the shareholders voted to sell BBE or take it public at some point in the future. By converting the preferred shares into common, VFI would share in any increase in the value of BBE and any consequent appreciation in the common shares.
The parties agree to meet again next Monday. This will give each side the opportunity to consider the issues raised in today's discussions.
If there is any financial term you would like explained, please submit it in a comment and I will try to answer your question.
Comments are always welcome and are posted within 24 hours of receipt.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)